preview

Analysis Of Shane, Destry Rides Again And Support Your Local Sheriff

Decent Essays

Shane, Destry Rides Again and Support Your Local Sheriff are classified as a classical plot of western films, so it is no doubt that they share similar structures. Shane, Destry, and McCullough exist in societies as strangers, but they use their special skills to defeat villains who threaten the citizens. Wright summarizes formulations to western films, which help audiences to recognize the differentiation in western films. He analyzes most films of classical plot into sixteen steps. On function of the classical plot is “The society does not completely accept the hero” (Wright 44). Wight indicates that the hero is not accepted by society, because the hero is not the member of society, he is strong, and his special ability. That means societies …show more content…

Shane, Destry and McCullough are skilled gunfighters without backgrounds. In other words, they are both strangers to societies. According to Wright’s function, they both should be rejected. However, McCullough gains a job as a sheriff in the town after he shows the gun skills. Destry gains respect and becomes a deputy after he plays the gun. Only Shane is rejected in homesteaders’ meeting, and the citizen is afraid of his expert gun skill. These societies all face the villains. Tow societies accepted heroes because they do not concern the background of the heroes, and they are desperate to need a powerful person who can release them from the villains’ control. They do not care the heroes use what kind of methods to gain victors, so they will not reject the men who can help them when they recognize the specific skills of the heroes. On the other hand, Shane is rejected because homesteaders’ do not want any violence to exist on their land. They even choose to leave the land to avoid villains instead of fighting back. The hero’s power does not only scar the villains but also scar the homesteaders. Society is afraid of violence as well as the villains. They want a man who can help them to defeat the villains but without violence, so they cannot accept the hero. Hence, Wright’s function does not fit in there, and his …show more content…

The classical plot emphasizes that society is always good and weak. There is no doubt that societies are weak, but if societies are good or not, it can be reflected through accepting the heroes or not. In Shane, the homesteaders do not accept Shane because they do not want using violence to gain peace. Gun means violence to them no matter whether people use them for good or bad reasons. Peace is the most important thing to the homesteaders. Another tow societies accept heroes, but the societies still have different characteristics. McCullough is accepted by the town and becomes a sheriff. There is no question that the town needs hero’s power to defeat villains, but the most important reason is no people in the town want to fight villains. They are selfish and afraid to die under guns. They accept McCullough because he owns special skills, and that skills can help the town to deal with their problems. They do not care about safety of the hero. Therefore, society absolutely cannot refuse a powerful man without background because they just want to use the hero’s own power to fix their problems. Destry also is accepted by society but society truly need him. Society is controlled by villains. The citizens try using their won power to fight villains, but they are too weak to fight them. Hence, after they realize Destry’s gun skills, they accept him as a deputy. The three societies are based on

Get Access