preview

Ethical Dilemmas In Health And Social Care Case Study

Decent Essays

1. Is there an ethical violation, dilemma or concern and, if so, what is it? By Madeline receiving a subpoena duces tecum, she is expected to personally appear at a deposition or in court with documents in hand. Though, the fact that the patient’s authorization to release his/her information is missing the date will make the subpoena duces tecum invalid. The ethical dilemma is created when Madeline calls the attorney’s office and informs the attorney’s legal assistant of the missing element on the authorization and she receives the same document with a date written within five minutes. This make Madeline suspects that the legal assistant was the one who wrote the date on the authorization and not the patient. Is it ethical to Madeline …show more content…

According to the AHIMA Code of Ethics Tenets: II. Put service and the health and welfare of persons before self-interest and conduct themselves in the practice of the profession so as to bring honor to themselves, their peers, and to the health information management profession. IV. Refuse to participate in or conceal unethical practices or procedures. o Madeline should go to the hospital ethics committee and ask for advice on how to address the ethical problem. Identify alternatives o Provide the records and appear at the deposition or the court and pretend that the date was not falsely written by the legal assistant. o Summit a motion to squash, which is a written objection to the subpoena, explaining that the subpoena duces tecum she received was not valid because the authorization from the patient was not dated. Call the legal assistant and let her know that she believes that she was the one that wrote the date and that she will not accept the document as valid since it was filled out properly by the patient Evaluate the

Get Access