In the Tale of Two Cities, Charles Dickens utilizes Sydney Carton to show the theme that love has transformative powers.
At the beginning of the novel Carton is presented as a lazy alcoholic who has no real prospects in life and doesn't seem to have any in the near future. However, as the novel progresses he reveals a versatile personality of nobility, loyalty, selflessness, and unconditional love for Lucie Manette. This love will transform him into a hero of sorts, fulfilling his potential he squanders working as background attorney for Stryer. Very early on, Carton’s negative outlook on life is expressed in the bar after the trial of Charles Darnay in England. Carton says to Charles in a drunken stupor, "I am a disappointed drudge, sir.
…show more content…
As a result of his unceasing love for Lucie and his physical likeness with Darnay, he was able to switch places with him in prison before being brought to the block to be beheaded by the guillotine. Carton, through this final act, fulfilled the promise he made to Lucie. When Carton is in line for the Guillotine he meets a seamstress who asks "Are you dying for him?" He responds with "And his wife and child." After Carton's death the narrator says, "They said of him, about the city that night, that it was the peacefullest man's face ever beheld there. Many added that he looked sublime and prophetic.” Sydney found peace by knowing his life had a meaning and purpose. He sacrificing his life for Love. Doing so saved not only Lucie, but her child and Darney as well. This is the ultimate act of selflessness and the act of a composed loyal man. Neither of which Carton possessed at the beginning of the book. The closing lines of the novel stating, "It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done; it is a far, far better rest that I go to than I have ever known.” Carton turned his life from that of a relatively lost pathetic man into that of a hero. Sydney finally became a man of his words, fulfilled a promise and allowing him to rest in peace knowing he will live on in the hearts and inheritance of the person he died
Lastly, good did triumph over evil in Sydney Carton. Sydney Carton is a drunk who hates Darnay because if Carton was not a drunk he would have everything Darnay has, like the love of Lucie Manette. Carton is seen as the darkness because of the disparity he has and how low he has fallen. Whereas Darnay is seen as light or the good guy due to how his life is going. In the end when Sydney gives up his life for Darnay it shows how Sydney is transferring from being sad and dark. His selfless act proved that the “bad” Sydney Carton has saved Darnay and kept Lucie, Cartons love, happy.
Carton has given up his own life to give Lucie and a child whom he’s never met a better life. A main theme in A Tale of Two Cities is loyalty, and Sydney Carton’s loyalty seems to lie with not only Lucie, but with everyone but himself.
Charles Darnay and Sydney Carton have pretty much in common, as well as their similar appearances and their love for Lucie. They even have terribly several variations as well as their backgrounds and attitudes. However, in the end, the reader finishes up having the
Sydney Carton, the alcoholic aid of an attorney is able to break out of his depressing shell and fulfill his promise to Lucie Manette by the end of A Tale of Two Cities. He shows himself as the true hero of the novel and shines over all the other characters that were “recalled to life” (7). The ultimate sacrifice, to give up one’s life, should be rewarded as the most heroic action in any situation out of good
This wasted potential is emphasized when both Darnay and Carton fall in love with Lucie Manette. Darnay, as the typical charming hero, is chosen over desperate, brooding Carton. As a result, Carton finds himself channeling his love and his physical advantage of being Darnay’s double into keeping Lucie safe and happy by way of rescuing Darnay from the guillotine. Thus, Carton is able to become the proverbial “good guy,” a role he saw for himself in his counterpart, Darnay. He also managed to thwart the Defarges’ plot to murder all those connected to the aristocracy in any way. In this way, Dickens is able to use the comparisons and contrasts between the two men to show how love is capable of victory over violence and vengeance.
Sydney’s position as a lawyer persuades his feelings of service. He fully shows the “ideology of service” as he gives his life to the service of his clients. To serve others, a person must have a sense of self-sacrifice; therefore, his profession as a lawyer “supplies a professional context for Carton’s self-sacrifice” (Petch 38). If not for Sydney’s profession and his self-sacrificial sense of duty, the end of the novel may have been extremely different.
Sydney Carton proved that his life was purposeless since he is always drunk and lazy, but he wants to make right decisions that would help others since he doesn’t really care about himself. Sydney finally tells Lucie Manette that he loves her bye he say’s, sorrow and repentance, blight you, disgrace you, pull you down with him”. Sydney say’s that he is not worth it and it will bring her down too.“For you, and for any dear to you, I would do anything . . . I would embrace any sacrifice for you and for those dear to you” (Dickens 156). Even though Sydney is lost and hopeless, he promises Lucie that he will be ready to give his life for her happiness. Sydney Carton comes a long way where it is hard for him to find it’s true potential. Sydney’s words are so fragile but later these words help him find freedom for himself and leave a mark, so people remember him.
Sydney Carton performs many courageous acts that create positive changes for the Evrémonde family’s future. Carton’s actions strive to improve the Evrémonde family’s life, while boldly putting his at risk. His fearless actions reunite the Evrémonde family back together, producing a new, positive outlook of the future for them. When Carton enters Darnay’s prison cell, it is described that Carton, “dressed himself in the clothes the prisoner had laid aside, combed back his hair, and tied it with the ribbon the prisoner had worn” (Dickens 358). Carton acts gallantly in order to salvage Darnay’s life, for he switches places with him in the prison. As a result of Carton’s brave actions, Darnay is free once more to be with his family and lead a
Sydney Carton's life is made meaningful by the hope that he receives from Lucy Manette. At the beginning of the story, Sydney Carton's life has no significance. He is a drunkard with a seemingly worthless life. Sydney is working as a clerk for the lawyer C.J. Stryver, and though Sydney is the real brains behind the ideas, the attorney receives all the credit. Carton has had an unfavorable life and has no inspiration, nothing to live for. Sydney really wants for his life to have served some purpose, for him to have made a difference. He changes his life around after a conversation with Miss Manette in which Carton professes his love to her. Carton
In the beginning, Sydney Carton’s the character that everyone looks down upon. He is depression, hate and self-loathing personified. His total carelessness overshadows anything else about him, especially when his first impression is given. Sydney is introduced when Charles
Similar to Jarvis Lorry, Sydney Carton undergoes a transformation of character. When Carton is first introduced in book one he is a pitiful lawyer, an “idlest and most unpromising man,”(Dickens 78). In chapter five he is displayed as an “amazingly good jackal,”(Dickens 79), meaning that he is “content and apathetic towards the fact that he will never be accredited with the performance and outcomes of his actions,”(Trojan, Kara). However, Lucie Manette inspires redemption in Carton through love, for he knows that if he can save her in any way then he can absolve his misery and find a purpose for his years on Earth. When Lucie Manette’s husband is punished to death row, Carton is determined to keep his promise. Carton takes the place of the spouse
In the beginning, Sydney Carton was a mean drunk that did nothing well and was only worried about himself. Carton had never done anything correctly, or for the benefit of others until he met Lucie, which was the love of his life, that he would do anything for. In another incident he shows his love for Lucie by dying in place of her husband, Charles Darnay, and when asked why he was dying for this man, his reply was, “ It is far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done: it is a far, far better rest that I go to than I have ever known” (446). Sydney Carton is basically saying that it was the best thing that he has ever done because he did not grow up doing things for other people’s better good. This shows how much he has changed from being a drunk and mean, to dying for the happiness of a person he loves. Sydney Carton has been greatly “recalled to life”, because he has changed so much, and it has made a huge impact in the book.
A Tale of Two Cities, written by Charles Dickens, takes place during the French Revolution. The book centers on the heroic attempts of Sydney Carton and Charles Darnay. Sydney Carton puts on the façade of being insolent and indifferent, but his true nature is expressed in the book when he puts others first, defends Charles, and dies for the ones he loves. Charles Darnay is a once wealthy aristocrat whose attempts at heroism include going back to France, his financial sacrifice, and the noble way in which he was willing to face his death.
Sydney Carton is portrayed as a person with merely any value at the beginning of the novel. He was described as “so careless as to be almost insolent” (Page 83) due to his behavior in the courtroom as being disrespectful and also due to his negligent physical appearance. For example, in the book it is said that, "Mr. Carton, who had long sat looking at the ceiling of the court, changed neither his place nor his attitude, even with this excitement” (Page 81). He frequently alludes to the fact that his life has been wasted, stating that he “cares for no man on earth and no man on earth cares for (him)” (Page 89). Shown frequently indulging in alcohol for instance during his conversation with Darnay after the trial, Carton is a drunkard. He is depicted as wasting his cleverness and youth on drink and carelessness. However, Carton sacrifices in many instance for the betterment of others which changes the perspective to look at him.
Throughout human history, many stories have been passed down and spread thanks to evolution, and the progress of literacy and entertainment. The image of a hero has ranged from superhero to a normal business man which has helped sprout a multitude of types of heroes. Charles Dickens’s A Tale of Two Cities presents the unlikely Sydney Carton as the one to surprisingly execute solutions for all the issues in the story. After finishing the book it’s become clear that Carton was a hero, but it’s unknown what type of hero he is; romantic or tragic. Although Sydney has qualities of both a romantic and a tragic hero, upon further research Sydney Carton demonstrates the qualities of a tragic hero. Comparing the archetype of a Tragic hero and Sydney Carton, many similarities can be seen. Some of these involve his destruction for a greater cause and being imperfect. Between the hero archetypes of a tragic and a romantic hero, Sydney Carton in A Tale of Two Cities, written by Charles Dickens, better fits the title of a tragic hero.