preview

Tax Research Memo Essay

Decent Essays

To: File
From: Xinxin Shi
RE: Paula Green and Mary Brown (tax year 2012)

Facts

Paula Green, a U.S citizen and our client, is preparing to expand her business into landscaping field. Before the expansion, Paula already has already been operating the Green Thumb Nursery whose total assets with a $260,000 adjusted basis and a $500,000 FMV. To avoid the risk of paying unlimited debt, Paula plans to change business form from sole proprietorship into corporation. And Mary Brown, a U.S citizen and the other client, would like to invest $250,000 into this corporation.
The Green Thumb Nursery has earned approximately $55,000 per year; both Paula and Mary estimate that the new corporation would incur loss of $50,000 per year for the next …show more content…

Both of them would be involved in operation of the business. 2. According to Sec. 351, Paula recognizes no gain, because she does not receive any boot. 3. All the stock is Sec. 1244 Stock. Under Sec. 1244, if Common stock is sold at loss or becomes worthless, the at least part of the loss would become ordinary loss that could be used to offset ordinary income. 4. Benefits of choosing to be S Corporation. According to Sec. 1361 and Reg.Sec. 1.1361-1, if Paula and Mary both consent to the special election made by the corporation, the corporation could be a S corporation so that in the first two years, Paula and Mary could use the loss to offset their income from other sources. If necessary, they could revoke the decision, turning the corporation back into C Corporation.
Disadvantage:
1. All distributions (excluding reasonable salary) to Paula and Mary will be taxed as dividends to them. And the corporation could not deduct this part of distribution. 2. Considering Mary’s need of assurance, it is possible that Mary would prefer other forms, like bond or preferred share, which have more assurance to repay her investment. 3. Mary may need to get return on this investment before she gets dividends. Because Paula gets hold over 50% of stock, it is up to Paula to make the final decision about when the corporation would distribute dividends to shareholders.

Option b:
Advantage:
1. Under Sec. 351, Paula would

Get Access