preview

Turn Of The Screw: The Governess

Decent Essays

In his novella The Turn of the Screw, Henry James allows the readers to be the judge of the governess's sanity by making her an ambiguous character. She explicitly states that she sees apparitions of past Bly residents, making her an honest narrator; however, there are times when her rationality is uncertain. Right Diagnosis, a medical website composed by certified doctors, states that aggression, suspicion, and hallucinations are all symptoms of insanity. The governess is insane because of her aggressiveness, excessive anxiety, and imagination of the ghosts. The governess is insane because her aggressive nature brings harm to the children. For example, the governess has a mental breakdown on the lake and accuses Flora of lying about seeing …show more content…

When she is watching Flora play at the lake, she sees the ghost of Miss Jessel. She thinks that Flora sees her when she says that "[Flora] had, in her play, turned her back to the water… [and] the governess's apprehension of what she was doing sustained [her]" (James 29). There is no evidence suggesting that Flora sees the apparition that the governess sees. The governess is afraid of what Flora is doing, even though she is simply playing by the lake. Since the governess is afraid of a ghost that Flora cannot see, indicating that it is not real at all, she is insane. Later in the story, Mrs. Grose points out that she cannot see the apparitions. She and the governess find Flora on the lake, but the governess notices that the ghost of Miss Jessel is also watching over them. After pointing her out, Mrs. Grose asks, "'What a dreadful turn, to be sure, miss! Where on earth do you see anything?'" to which Flora replies, "'I see nothing,'" (James 71). This shows that the governess sees things that are not real. Instead, these images are just part of her own imagination and are unverifiable because the other characters cannot see them. The governess is a deranged woman because, according to the other characters, the ghosts she sees are not …show more content…

After her second encounter with Quint, the governess confesses her concerns to Mrs. Grose about this mysterious man. Upon learning that the man is actually a ghost, the governess resolves to shield the children from this new danger. However, she does not undertake this task out of the goodness of her heart, but for the praise she would receive for her effort. She is insane because her initial thought is uplifting her personal image rather than protecting the children. Immediately after realizing that it will be an arduous effort, she notes that "there would be a greatness in letting it be seen--oh, in the right quarter!" (James 27). The governess does not think to guard the children from harm; instead, she wishes to improve her reputation. She wants to acquire the approval of her associates and her peers before thinking about guarding the children. Therefore, she demonstrates extreme insanity because her first concern was her self image rather than the children's safety. It is also possible to argue that the ghosts are real because the governess thinks that Miles can see Quint through the window. When Quint materializes before the governess, she obscures him from Miles's view in order to protect him. However, it is impossible that Miles even saw Quint at the window. Immediately after saying Quint's name, he asks "Where?" then "jerk[s] straight round,

Get Access