In William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, Lady Capulet and the Nurse are responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet because Lady Capulet is pragmatic and the Nurse is irresponsible. Lady Capulet's traditional views on love and forcing her daughter to marry Paris are two examples in which Lady Capulet shows us that being pragmatic was the cause for the lover’s deaths. Compared to Juliet, Lady Capulet is very pragmatic when its comes to views on the meaning and ideas of love. Her opinion is that the tradition of arranged marriages is correct, as in that marriage should be arranged by your parents and you should do what you are told. Lady Capulet instructs Juliet to seek out her future husband at the party and asks her, “What say you? Can you love the gentleman? This night you shall behold him at our feast” (1.3.85-100). Lady Capulet, who married at a young age, offers complete support for her husband’s plan for their daughter, and puts pressure on Juliet to think about Paris as a husband even before Juliet has begun to think about marriage at all. Considering the fact that a marriage to Paris would bring increasing social status and wealth for the Capulets, it’s reasonable to say that Lady Capulet was thinking about this situation pragmatically. Assuming that Lady Capulet is still quite young herself, she should be able to remember her feelings of being forced into an arranged marriage and use them to persuade Juliet in a different approach. If Lady Capulet had put less pressure on Juliet to marry Paris or consider the fact that she might not even want to marry for social status or wealth, Juliet's death might not have taken place in the way it did. When Juliet rebels against the planned marriage with Paris, she's rebelling against her mother's way of life, and against the kind of marriage that Lady Capulet learned to suffer through. After Juliet refuses to marry Paris as her parents wish, Lady Capulet comes in and responds, "Talk not to me, for I'll not say a word Do as thou wilt, for I have done with thee" (3.5.15). These words express how Lady Capulet is an irresponsible mother. She declares that she is done with this entire situation showing that she's ineffectual. There is a major change from the
Some people may think the Nurse and Friar Lawrence is ultimately to blame for Romeo and Juliet deaths. The Nurse and Friar Lawrence both kept secrets. The Nurse told Juliet to marry Paris and the Friar knew Juliet was brave enough to take the sleeping potion and fake her death. Fate and
Capulet could be the character to blame for the death of Romeo and Juliet, because he forced Juliet into marrying Paris. Capulet thinks that her marrying Paris will bring her happiness and plans a wedding for her. But when he informs Juliet about the wedding, she doesn't want to marry Paris. Capulet's response to this is, "Hang thee,
Everyone has their different opinions on who is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. Romeo and Juliet is about two people that fall in love from two different families who are in a feud with each other. Lord Capulet is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet because when Romeo was at the Capulet part he didn’t let Tybalt do anything to make Romeo leave. Reason two is he is the one that planned for Juliet to get married to Paris without her consent. The third reason is because after Juliet says okay to marrying Paris (going along with the Friar’s plan), Lord Capulet tries moving the wedding day up to Wednesday instead of Thursday.
Despite all of these actions which ultimately ended in chaos, I don't think that the Friar or the Nurse were to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. On some level their actions did partake in what eventuated in the tragedy, but they came with the best intentions, with high hopes that they would be able to save a young couple's love and end a bitter feud. Friar Laurence did bring the families together, but it was with death rather than marriage. O brother Montague, give me thy hand. (V, 3, 232)
This does not allow Juliet to make her own decision. An example of this is when Lady Capulet reinforces the plan in which Paris would be Juliet's husband, rather than letting Juliet choose who she marries. Lady Capulet speaks for Juliet when she says “marry, my child, early next Thursday morn.” Having little to no knowledge aforetime about this news, Juliet is utterly astonished. Lady Capulet continues by saying “[the] young and noble gentleman, the county Paris... shall happily make thee there a joyful bride” (III.v.112-115). After having already prepared her life with Romeo, Juliet is in disbelief that her mother would not attempt to step into her father's plan. Juliet lashes back at her mother by saying “I will not marry yet” and threatening that she would marry Romeo “whom you know I hate” rather than Paris (III.v.115-122). The lack of communication between the two characters makes them distant from one another, and the little effort provided by Lady Capulet to approach her daughter is the main reason for this occurrence. The control Lady Capulet has over different characters and her
There are numerous important speeches in the novel Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare. I feel that one of the most important ones is the speech that is spoken by Lady Capulet about Juliet marrying Paris in Act 1 scene 3. It is prominent because it is the first time the we see the relationship that Lady Capulet and Juliet have with each other. Lady Capulet expects Juliet to listen to everything she is told and not have any complaints. Juliet on the other hand, is reluctant to agree to marry Paris because she does not want to be forced to marry someone she does not love. Juliet says gently, "It is an honor that I dreamt not of."
In Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, the Nurse, by her thoughtless support of the affair between the lovers and fickle counsel, is partly to blame for the tragedy. However, it is not one factor alone that brings about the death of Romeo and Juliet, but a combination of significant actions and underlying forces.
In Shakespeare’s play Romeo and Juliet the characters Nurse and Friar Laurence are to blame for Romeo and Juliet’s Problems.
He changes his mind very quickly and can flip-flop between what he wants for Juliet. For example, as Paris and Capulet are talking to each other Paris asks Lord Capulet for his permission to marry Juliet. Capulet then replies, “My will to her consent is but a part. And, she agreed, within her scope of choice lies my consent and fair according voice.” (1.2.17-19). In this quote, Lord Capulet is saying that his decision is only a part and if Juliet agrees to marry Paris his blessing will confirm her choice. Soon after Tybalt’s death, Capulet and Paris speak to one another once again. Tybalt suggests marrying Juliet to stop her mourning over the death of her cousin, Tybalt, and Lord Capulet agrees. Once Lord Capulet hears Juliet’s perspective on not marrying Paris he threatens her by saying, “I tell thee what: get thee to church o’ Thursday, or never after look me in the face” (3.5.167-168). This quote shows that Lord Capulet is forcing Juliet to marry Paris or else she cannot return back home. He doesn’t listen to Juliet’s opinion and seems to not care if she is happy or not with the marriage. This proves that Lord Capulet is fickle and is most responsible for Juliet’s
The father-child relationship between Lord Capulet and Juliet is a very strong one; during the beginning of the play Capulet is seen as a caring and protective father who wants what is best for his daughter. Shakespeare uses many techniques to present the relationship between Capulet and Juliet; the most common technique he uses is dramatic irony. Dramatic irony is utilized to develop tension within the audience; this tension builds up to the climax in Act 3 Scene 5 which is a turning point in their relationship.
In Act 1, scene ii. Capulet appeared to be a kind hearted man and he defers to Juliet’s ability to choose for herself, “My will to her concent is but a part” (I.ii.15). Juliet’s mother, Lady Capulet also has an influence over Juliet and her life and puts pressure on Juliet to marry Paris (the suitor that her father picked for her to marry). Juliet admits the power of the influence of her parents when she says of Paris, “I look to like, looking liking move; / But no more deep will I endart mine eye / Than your consent gives strength to fly” (I.iii.100-101). The specter of parental influence is very evident in this scene and it shows the influence of the society that they lived in.
What is most responsible for the two lovely lover-Romeo and Juliet’s death? In my opinion, there is no one particular person to really blame on their death. However, it is every single person are should be blamed for the deaths of both Romeo and Juliet. If I was answering the question of who were the few most responsible people for their tragedy-it would be three people. Because of people’s decision and different point of view, the people most responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet are Lady Capulet, Nurse, and Friar Lawrence.
Romeo and Juliet is set in Verona and it is based on two families, the
Someone might think the nurse is to blame because she kept the ongoing relationship between Romeo and Juliet and communicated between the two when they didn't see each other. "You know not how to choose a man" (dupler 3) The nurse was trying to prevent the relationship from happening as soon as it started. The nurse tried to urge Juliet into marrying count Paris when her father told her she had too no question about it. The nurse wanted what was best for Juliet and she knew Romeo want and count Paris was because he would be stable for her and provide for her. The nurse cannot be to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet because the nurse was trying to urge Juliet away from Romeo and just marry count Paris like her father wanted her too and live a happy life with
As a woman, Lady Capulet can relate to how Juliet feels when she is told she is to marry Paris. However, as a wife, she cannot voice an opinion of who or when Juliet is to marry. She is experienced, and asks Juliet, "Speak briefly: can you like of Paris’ love" (1.3.98). Because she is the caretaker, she respects Juliet’s feelings, but she can do nothing, even if Juliet does not learn to love Paris. Perhaps she asks this question because her own mother never asked it. She may want to know her daughter’s opinion, because until a woman is married, she has all the rights of a man according to Pitt. However, the father ruled over his daughter, and it was virtually impossible to remain unmarried while the father held all the decision making (14).