Recognizing pension expense
The annual examination of Felton Company’s financial statements by its external public accounting firm (auditors) is nearing completion. The following conversation took place between the controller of Felton Company (Francie) and the audit manager from the public accounting firm (Sumana):
Sumana: You know, Francie, we are about to wrap up our audit for this fiscal year. Yet, there is one item still to be resolved.
Francie: What’s that?
Sumana: Well, as you know, at the beginning of the year, Felton began a defined benefit pension plan. This plan promises your employees an annual payment when they retire, using a formula based on their salaries at retirement and their years of service. I believe that a pension expense should be recognized this year, equal to the amount of pension earned by your employees.
Francie: Wait a minute. I think you have it all wrong. The company doesn’t have a pension expense until it actually pays the pension in cash when the employee retires. After all, some of these employees may not reach retirement, and if they don’t, the company doesn’t owe them anything.
Sumana: You’re not really seeing this the right way. The pension is earned by your employees during their working years. You actually make the payment much later—when they retire. It’s like one long accrual—much like incurring wages in one period and paying them in the next. Thus, I think you should recognize the expense in the period the pension is earned by the employees.
Francie: Let me see if I’ve got this straight. I should recognize an expense this period for something that may or may not be paid to the employees in 20 or 30 years, when they finally retire. How am I supposed to determine what the expense is for the current year? The amount of the final retirement depends on many uncertainties: salary levels, employee longevity, mortality rates, and interest earned on investments to fund the pension. I don’t think an amount can be determined even if I accepted your arguments.
Evaluate Sumana’s position. Is she right, or is Francie correct?
Trending nowThis is a popular solution!
Chapter 11 Solutions
Financial Accounting
- You are the audit senior responsible for the audit of Sampson Limited. You are currently planning theaudit for the year ended 31 December 20X7. During your initial planning meeting held with thefinancial controller, he told you of the following changes in the company’s operations.(i) Due to the financial controller’s workload, the company has employed a treasurer. The financialcontroller is excited about the appointment because in the two months that the treasurer hasbeen with the company he has realised a small profit for the company through foreign-exchangetransactions in yen.(ii) Sampson has planned to close an inefficient factory in country New South Wales before the endof 20X7. It is expected that the redeployment and disposal of the factory’s assets will not becompleted until the end of the following year. However, the financial controller is confident thathe will be able to determine reasonably accurate closure provisions.(iii) To help achieve the budgeted sales for the year,…arrow_forwardYou are the audit senior responsible for the audit of Sampson Limited. You are currently planning theaudit for the year ended 31 December 20X7. During your initial planning meeting held with thefinancial controller, he told you of the following changes in the company’s operations.(i) Due to the financial controller’s workload, the company has employed a treasurer. The financialcontroller is excited about the appointment because in the two months that the treasurer hasbeen with the company he has realised a small profit for the company through foreign-exchangetransactions in yen.(ii) Sampson has planned to close an inefficient factory in country New South Wales before the endof 20X7. It is expected that the redeployment and disposal of the factory’s assets will not becompleted until the end of the following year. However, the financial controller is confidentthat he will be able to determine reasonably accurate closure provisions.(iii) To help achieve the budgeted sales for the year,…arrow_forwardYou are the audit senior responsible for the audit of Sampson Limited. You are currently planning theaudit for the year ended 31 December 20X7. During your initial planning meeting held with thefinancial controller, he told you of the following changes in the company’s operations.(i) Due to the financial controller’s workload, the company has employed a treasurer. The financialcontroller is excited about the appointment because in the two months that the treasurer hasbeen with the company he has realised a small profit for the company through foreign-exchangetransactions in yen.(ii) Sampson has planned to close an inefficient factory in country New South Wales before the endof 20X7. It is expected that the redeployment and disposal of the factory’s assets will not becompleted until the end of the following year. However, the financial controller is confident thathe will be able to determine reasonably accurate closure provisions.(iii) To help achieve the budgeted sales for the year,…arrow_forward
- You are the manager responsible for the audit of Bole Company, a chain of health and leisure clubs owned and managed by the Phil Addis family. The audit for the year ended 30 November 2019 is nearing completion and the draft financial statements recognize total assets of GH¢27 million and profit before tax of GH¢2.2 million. The audit senior has left the following file notes for your consideration during your review of the audit working papers.1. Cash transfers During a review of the cash book, a receipt of GH¢350,000 was identified which was accompanied by the description ‘BD’. Bank statements showed that the following day a nearly identical amount was transferred into a bank account held in a foreign country. When I asked the financial controller about this, she requested that I speak to Mr. Addis, as he has sole responsibility for cash management. According to Mr. Addis, an old friend of his, Ababa Ethiop, has loaned the money to the company to fund further expansion and the money…arrow_forwardYou are the audit senior responsible for the audit of Sampson Limited. You are currently planning the audit for the year ended 31 December 20X7. During your initial planning meeting held with the financial controller, he told you of the following changes in the company’s operations. (i)Due to the financial controller’s workload, the company has employed a treasurer. The financial controller is excited about the appointment because in the two months that the treasurer has been with the company he has realized a small profit for the company through foreign-exchange transactions in yen. (ii)Sampson has planned to close an inefficient factory in country New South Wales before the end of 20X7. It is expected that the redeployment and disposal of the factory’s assets will not be completed until the end of the following year. However, the financial controller is confident that he will be able to determine reasonably accurate closure provisions. (iii)To help achieve the budgeted sales for the…arrow_forwardYou are the audit senior responsible for the audit of Sampson Limited. You are currently planning theaudit for the year ended 31 December 20X7. During your initial planning meeting held with thefinancial controller, he told you of the following changes in the company’s operations.(i) Due to the financial controller’s workload, the company has employed a treasurer. The financialcontroller is excited about the appointment because in the two months that the treasurer hasbeen with the company he has realised a small profit for the company through foreign-exchangetransactions in yen.(ii) Sampson has planned to close an inefficient factory in country New South Wales before the endof 20X7. It is expected that the redeployment and disposal of the factory’s assets will not becompleted until the end of the following year. However, the financial controller is confident thathe will be able to determine reasonably accurate closure provisions.(iii) To help achieve the budgeted sales for the year,…arrow_forward
- While assisting the accounting department with completing the current year's financial statements, you have been asked to review a list of contingent liabilities. How would a manager, review the list of contingent liabilities and determine their probability?arrow_forwardYou are the audit senior responsible for the audit of Sampson Limited. You are currently planning the audit for the year ended 31 December 20X7. During your initial planning meeting held with the financial controller, he told you of the following changes in the company’s operations.(i) Due to the financial controller’s workload, the company has employed a treasurer. The financial controller is excited about the appointment because in the two months that the treasurer has been with the company he has realised a small profit for the company through foreign-exchange transactions in yen.(ii) Sampson has planned to close an inefficient factory in country New South Wales before the end of 20X7. It is expected that the redeployment and disposal of the factory’s assets will not be completed until the end of the following year. However, the financial controller is confident that he will be able to determine reasonably accurate closure provisions.(iii) To help achieve the budgeted sales for the…arrow_forwardEthics Case Suppose an auditor has been paid $1,000,000 each year for the past several years to perform the audit of a company's annual financial statements. This company is the auditor's largest client. In the current year, the auditor notices that the preliminary income statement excludes certain expenses that typically are shown. When asked, management tells the auditor that these expenses do not reflect the company's true performance, so they will not be shown in this year's income statement. Plus, management informs the auditor it will be paying $1,200,000 for this year's audit, and management commits to using the auditor for at least five more years. Required: 1. Understand the reporting effect: Does the audit arrangement described above have the potential to jeopardize the auditor's opinion of management's decision not to report certain expenses? 2. Specify the options: Are auditors employees of the company who must accept requests of management? 3. Identify the impact: Do…arrow_forward
- Develop audit procedures for the use of analytical procedures as a substantive procedure in the testing of the reasonableness of monthly payroll costs for the year Develop audit procedures for the use of analytical procedures in the planning phase to identify significant changes in operating and financial activities of the firm over previous years Identify benefits of using analytical procedures in the audit process May I get some assistance with these questions pleasearrow_forwardYou have been recently hired as an assistant controller for XYZ Industries, a large, publically held manufacturing company. Your immediate supervisor is the controller who also reports directly to the VP of Finance. The controller has assigned you the task of preparing the year-end adjusting entries. In the receivables area, you have prepared an aging accounts receivable and have applied historical percentages to the balances of each of the age categories. The analysis indicates that an appropriate estimated balance for the allowance for uncollectible accounts is $180,000. The existing balance in the allowance account prior to any adjusting entry is a $20,000 credit balance. After showing your analysis to the controller, he tells you to change the aging category of a large account from over 120 days to current status and to prepare a new invoice to the customer with a revised date that agrees with the new category. This will change the required allowance for uncollectible accounts…arrow_forwardYou have been recently hired as an assistant controller for XYZ Industries, a large, publically held manufacturing company. Your immediate supervisor is the controller who also reports directly to the VP of Finance. The controller has assigned you the task of preparing the year-end adjusting entries. In the receivables area, you have prepared an aging accounts receivable and have applied historical percentages to the balances of each of the age categories. The analysis indicates that an appropriate estimated balance for the allowance for uncollectible accounts is $180,000. The existing balance in the allowance account prior to any adjusting entry is a $20,000 credit balance. After showing your analysis to the controller, he tells you to change the aging category of a large account from over 120 days to current status and to prepare a new invoice to the customer with a revised date that agrees with the new category. This will change the required allowance for uncollectible accounts…arrow_forward
- Financial AccountingAccountingISBN:9781337272124Author:Carl Warren, James M. Reeve, Jonathan DuchacPublisher:Cengage Learning