Paterson Company,* a U.S.-based company, manufactures and sells electronic components worldwide. Virtually all its manufacturing takes place in the United States. The company has marketing divisions throughout Europe, including France. Debbie Kishimoto, manager of this division, was hired from a competitor 3 years ago. Debbie, recently informed of a price increase in one of the major product lines, requested a meeting with Jeff Phillips, marketing vice president. Their conversation follows.
Debbie: “Jeff, I simply don’t understand why the price of our main product has increased from $5.00 to $5.50 per unit. We negotiated an agreement earlier in the year with our manufacturing division in Philadelphia for a price of $5.00 for the entire year. I called the manager of that division. He said that the original price was still acceptable—that the increase was a directive from headquarters. That’s why I wanted to meet with you. I need some explanations. When I was hired, I was told that pricing decisions were made by the divisions. This directive interferes with this decentralized philosophy and will lower my division’s profits. Given current market conditions, there is no way we can pass on the cost increase. Profits for my division will drop at least $600,000 if this price is maintained. I think a midyear increase of this magnitude is unfair to my division.”
Jeff: “Under normal operating conditions, headquarters would not interfere with divisional decisions. But as a company, we are having some problems. What you just told me is exactly why the price of your product has been increased. We want the profits of all our European marketing divisions to drop.”
Debbie: “What do you mean that you want the profits to drop? That doesn’t make any sense. Aren’t we in business to make money?”
Jeff: “Debbie, what you lack is corporate perspective. We are in business to make money, and that’s why we want European profits to decrease. Our U.S. divisions are not doing well this year. Projections show significant losses. At the same time, projections for European operations show good profitability. By increasing the cost of key products transferred to Europe—to your division, for example—we increase revenues and profits in the United States. By decreasing your profits, we avoid paying taxes in France. With losses on other U.S. operations to offset the corresponding increase in domestic profits, we avoid paying taxes in the United States as well. The net effect is a much-needed increase in our cash flow. Besides, you know how hard it is in some of these European countries to transfer out capital. This is a clean way of doing it.”
Debbie: “I’m not so sure that it’s clean. I can’t imagine the tax laws permitting this type of scheme. There is another problem, too. You know that the company’s bonus plans are tied to a division’s profits. This plan could cost all of the European managers a lot of money.”
Jeff: “Debbie, you have no reason to worry about the effect on your bonus—or on our evaluation of your performance. Corporate management has already taken steps to ensure no loss of compensation. The plan is to compute what income would have been if the old price had prevailed and base bonuses on that figure. I’ll meet with the other divisional managers and explain the situation to them as well.”
Debbie: “The bonus adjustment seems fair, although I wonder if the reasons for the drop in profits will be remembered in a couple of years when I’m being considered for promotion. Anyway, I still have some strong ethical concerns about this. How does this scheme relate to the tax laws?”
Jeff: “We will be in technical compliance with the tax laws. In the United States, Section 482 of the Internal Revenue Code governs this type of transaction. The key to this law, as well as most European laws, is evidence of an arm’s-length price. Since you’re a distributor, we can use the resale price method to determine such a price. Essentially, the arm’s-length price for the transferred good is backed into by starting with the price at which you sell the product and then adjusting that price for the markup and other legitimate differences, such as tariffs and transportation.”
Debbie: “If I were a French tax auditor, I would wonder why the markup dropped from last year to this year. Are we being good citizens and meeting the fiscal responsibilities imposed on us by each country in which we operate?”
Jeff: “Well, a French tax auditor might wonder about the drop in markup. But, the markup is still within reason, and we can make a good argument for increased costs. In fact, we’ve already instructed the managers of our manufacturing divisions to legitimately reassign as many costs as they can to the European product lines. So far, they have been very successful. I think our records will support the increase that you are receiving. You really do not need to be concerned with the tax authorities. Our tax department assures me that this has been carefully researched—it’s unlikely that a tax audit will create any difficulties. It’ll all be legal and above board. We’ve done this several times in the past with total success.”
Required:
- 1. Do you think that the tax-minimization scheme described to Debbie Kishimoto is in harmony with the ethical behavior that should be displayed by top corporate executives? Why or why not? What would you do if you were Debbie?
- 2. Apparently, the tax department of Paterson Company has been strongly involved in developing the tax-minimization scheme. Assume that the accountants responsible for the decision are CMAs and members of the IMA, subject to the IMA standards of ethical conduct. Review the IMA standards for ethical conduct in Chapter 1. Are any of these standards being violated by the accountants in Paterson’s tax department? If so, identify them. What should these tax accountants do if requested to develop a questionable taxminimization scheme?
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter 13 Solutions
Managerial Accounting: The Cornerstone of Business Decision-Making
- Mirabel Manufacturing is a small but growing company that manufactures and sells marine sonar equipment. They employee a national sales force and their primary customers are marine retailers and boat dealerships. The company has expanded over the last 5 years and Paul Mirabel, the founder and CEO has become concerned that he no longer has a clear picture of their cost structure. He calls his CFO, Mary Jane Montgomery in for a meeting. “Mary Jane, I am concerned that I am not current on our cost structure and how that is impacting our bottom line,” Paul begins. “Well, Paul, the company has grown considerably over the past 5 years, so I’m not surprised that you feel a little disconnected with how things are going,” Mary Jane replied. She continued “In fact, I’ve been meaning to talk to you about a couple of big items such as increasing the sales commission to 15%. We’ve lost two of our best account managers in the last 9 months. It seems like we are behind the curve paying only 12% on…arrow_forwardMirabel Manufacturing is a small but growing company that manufactures and sells marine sonar equipment. They employee a national sales force and their primary customers are marine retailers and boat dealerships. The company has expanded over the last 5 years and Paul Mirabel, the founder and CEO has become concerned that he no longer has a clear picture of their cost structure. He calls his CFO, Mary Jane Montgomery in for a meeting. “Mary Jane, I am concerned that I am not current on our cost structure and how that is impacting our bottom line,” Paul begins. “Well, Paul, the company has grown considerably over the past 5 years, so I’m not surprised that you feel a little disconnected with how things are going,” Mary Jane replied. She continued “In fact, I’ve been meaning to talk to you about a couple of big items such as increasing the sales commission to 15%. We’ve lost two of our best account managers in the last 9 months. It seems like we are behind the curve paying only 12% on…arrow_forwardWheels, Inc. is a manufacturer of bicycles sold through retail bicycle shops in the southeastern United States. The company has two salespeople who do more than just sell the products-they manage relationships with the bicycle shops to enable them to better meet consumers' needs. The company's sales reps visit the shops several times per year, often for hours at a time. The owner of Wheels is considering expanding to the rest of the country and would like to have distribution through 4000 bicycle shops. To do so, however, the company would have to hire more salespeople. Each salesperson earns $40000 plus 2 percent commission on all sales. Another alternative is to use the services of sales agents instead of its own salesforce. Sales agents would be paid 4 percent of sales. Each sales call lasts approximately 1.7 hours, and each sales rep has approximately 1360 hours per year to devote to customers. Wheels needs 10 salespeople if it has 4,000 bicycle shop accounts that need to be…arrow_forward
- Mirabel Manufacturing is a small but growing company that manufactures and sells marine sonar equipment. They employee a national sales force and their primary customers are marine retailers and boat dealerships. The company has expanded over the last 5 years and Paul Mirabel, the founder and CEO has become concerned that he no longer has a clear picture of their cost structure. He calls his CFO, Mary Jane Montgomery in for a meeting. “Mary Jane, I am concerned that I am not current on our cost structure and how that is impacting our bottom line,” Paul begins. “Well, Paul, the company has grown considerably over the past 5 years, so I’m not surprised that you feel a little disconnected with how things are going,” Mary Jane replied. She continued “In fact, I’ve been meaning to talk to you about a couple of big items such as increasing the sales commission to 15%. We’ve lost two of our best account managers in the last 9 months. It seems like we are behind the curve paying only 12% on…arrow_forwardMirabel Manufacturing is a small but growing company that manufactures and sells marine sonar equipment. They employee a national sales force and their primary customers are marine retailers and boat dealerships. The company has expanded over the last 5 years and Paul Mirabel, the founder and CEO has become concerned that he no longer has a clear picture of their cost structure. He calls his CFO, Mary Jane Montgomery in for a meeting. “Mary Jane, I am concerned that I am not current on our cost structure and how that is impacting our bottom line,” Paul begins. “Well, Paul, the company has grown considerably over the past 5 years, so I’m not surprised that you feel a little disconnected with how things are going,” Mary Jane replied. She continued “In fact, I’ve been meaning to talk to you about a couple of big items such as increasing the sales commission to 15%. We’ve lost two of our best account managers in the last 9 months. It seems like we are behind the curve paying only 12% on…arrow_forwardMirabel Manufacturing is a small but growing company that manufactures and sells marine sonar equipment. They employee a national sales force and their primary customers are marine retailers and boat dealerships. The company has expanded over the last 5 years and Paul Mirabel, the founder and CEO has become concerned that he no longer has a clear picture of their cost structure. He calls his CFO, Mary Jane Montgomery in for a meeting. “Mary Jane, I am concerned that I am not current on our cost structure and how that is impacting our bottom line,” Paul begins. “Well, Paul, the company has grown considerably over the past 5 years, so I’m not surprised that you feel a little disconnected with how things are going,” Mary Jane replied. She continued “In fact, I’ve been meaning to talk to you about a couple of big items such as increasing the sales commission to 15%. We’ve lost two of our best account managers in the last 9 months. It seems like we are behind the curve paying only 12% on…arrow_forward
- suppose that your sister Angelina Humphrey is a manager of a regional glass producer. this company was recently acquired by Big Frame Ltd, the largest frame maker in victoria. in a meeting with Big Frame's management board, Angelina is informed that her business division is required to supply glass to the frame division. she is suggested to meet with the frame division's manager and discuss a transfer price. however, Angelina does not understand what transfer price means and how this term might affect her business division. required: briefly explain transfer pricing to angelina and how it will impact her business division's performance in the future.arrow_forwardORANGE PRODUCTS INC. Orange Products Inc. is a producer of juice drinks in Florida, USA. Until now, the company has confined its operations and sales to the United States, but its CEO, Ray Jalkio wants to expand into the Pacific Rim. The first step is to set up sales subsidiaries in Japan and Australia. then to set a production plant in Japan, and finally to distribute the product throughout the Pacific Rim. The firm's CFO, Janet Jackson, is enthusiastic about the plan, but she is worried about the implications of the foreign expansion on the firm's financial management process. She has asked your group to develop a tutorial package that explains the basics of multinational financial management. The tutorial will be presented at the next management committee (ManCom) meeting. Consider the following exchange rates: US Dollar Required to buy one unit of Foreign Currency Japanese Yen Australian Dollar Number of units of Foreign Currency per US Dollar 109.89 1.316 0.0091 0.760 1. Orange…arrow_forwardWheels, Inc. manufactures bicycles sold through retail bicycle shops in the southeastern United States. The company has two salespeople that do more than just sell the products - they manage relationships with the bicycle shops to enable them to better meet consumers' needs. The company's sales reps visit the shops several times per year, often for hours at a time. The owner of Wheels is considering expanding to the rest of the country and would like to have distribution through 450 bicycle shops. To do so, however, the company would have to hire more salespeople. Each salesperson earns $30,000 plus 3 percent commission on all sales annually. Another alternative is to use the services of sales agents instead of its own sales force. Sales agents would be paid 6 percent of sales. Each sales call lasts approximately 3 hours, and each sales rep has approximately 675 hours per year to devote to customers. Wheels needs 6 salespeople if it has 450 bicycle shop accounts that need to be called…arrow_forward
- Wheels Inc. is a manufacturer of bicycles sold through retail bicycle shops in the southeastern United States. The company has two sales people that do more than just sell the product-they manage relationships with the bicycle shops to enable them to better meet the consumers' needs. The company's sales reps visits the shop several times per year, often for hours at a time. The owner of wheels is considering expanding to the rest of the country and would like to have distribution through 1000 bicycle shops. To do so, Howe the company would have to hire more salespeople. Each sales person earn $40,000 plus 2 percent commission on all sales. Another alternative is to use the services of sales agents instead of its own sales force. Sales agents would be paid 5 percent of sales. a) determine the number of sales people Wheels need if it has 1000 bicycle shop accounts that need to be called on four time per year. Each sales call lasts approximately 2.5 hours, and each sales rep has…arrow_forwardYou are the Cookie division controller for Auntie M’s Baked Goods Company. Auntie M recently introduced a new chocolate chip cookie brand called Full of Chips, which has more than twice as many chips as any other brand on the market. The brand has quickly become a huge market success, largely because of the number of chips in each cookie. As a result of the brand’s success, the product manager who launched the Full of Chips brand has been promoted to division vice president. A new product manager, Brandon, has been brought in to replace the promoted manager.At Auntie M’s, product managers are evaluated on both the sales and profit margin of the products they manage. During his first week on the job, Brandon notices that the Full of Chips cookie uses a lot of chips, which increases the cost of the cookie. To improve the product’s profitability, Brandon plans to reduce the amount of chips per cookie by 10%. He believes that a 10% reduction in chips will not adversely affect sales, but…arrow_forwardYou are the Cookie division controller for Auntie M’s Baked Goods Company. Auntie M recently introduced a new chocolate chip cookie brand called Full of Chips, which has more than twice as many chips as any other brand on the market. The brand has quickly become a huge market success, largely because of the number of chips in each cookie. As a result of the brand’s success, the product manager who launched the Full of Chips brand has been promoted to division vice president. A new product manager, Brandon, has been brought in to replace the promoted manager. At Auntie M’s, product managers are evaluated on both the sales and profit margin of the products they manage. During his first week on the job, Brandon notices that the Full of Chips cookie uses a lot of chips, which increases the cost of the cookie. To improve the product’s profitability, Brandon plans to reduce the amount of chips per cookie by 10%. He believes that a 10% reduction in chips will not adversely affect sales, but…arrow_forward
- Principles of Accounting Volume 2AccountingISBN:9781947172609Author:OpenStaxPublisher:OpenStax CollegeAuditing: A Risk Based-Approach to Conducting a Q...AccountingISBN:9781305080577Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. RittenbergPublisher:South-Western College PubManagerial Accounting: The Cornerstone of Busines...AccountingISBN:9781337115773Author:Maryanne M. Mowen, Don R. Hansen, Dan L. HeitgerPublisher:Cengage Learning