Dividends versus Reinvestment [LO2] After completing its capital spending for the year, Carlson Manufacturing has $1,000 extra cash. Carlson’s managers must choose between investing the cash in Treasury bonds that yield 3 percent or paying the cash out to investors who would invest in the bonds themselves.
a. If the corporate tax rate is 35 percent, what personal tax rate would make the investors equally willing to receive the dividend or to let Carlson invest the money?
b. Is the answer to (a) reasonable? Why or why not?
c. Suppose the only investment choice is a
a)
To determine: The personal tax rate.
Introduction:
C manufacturing company has 1000 extra cash. The managers decide to invest the cash in treasury bills that yield 3% or to pay the cash out to the investors.
Answer to Problem 16QP
Explanation of Solution
Given information:
The corporate tax rate is 35%.
Determine the personal tax rate:
Note: Consider the tax rate as ‘
Compute the individual after-tax dividend:
Therefore, the after-tax dividend can be invested in treasury bonds.
Compute the after-tax cash flow from treasury bonds:
Note: Let this be equation 1.
Compute the proceeds if the firm invests the money:
Compute the proceeds if the firm pays dividend:
Note: Let this be equation 2.
Whether the investors invest the after-tax dividend or receive the proceeds from the firm’s investment, the investors’ proceeds will be the same.
Solve these two equations to find the rate of indifference.
Therefore, the personal tax rate that makes the investors equally and fairly willing to obtain the dividend or C to invest money is 35%
b)
To discuss: Whether the above solution is reasonable or not.
Explanation of Solution
Yes, the above solution is reasonable.
Person C is indifferent if the after-tax proceeds from the $1,000 investments in the securities are identical. The above indifference occurs only when the tax rates are identical.
c)
To determine: The personal tax rate.
Answer to Problem 16QP
Explanation of Solution
Given information:
The preferred stocks yield at 6%, seventy percentage of income is exempted from the corporate taxes, and person C gets more benefits by investing in stocks.
Compute the personal tax rate:
The same answer in part (a) will apply to this, as the pretax returns are the same.
The seventy percentage of income is exempted from the corporate taxes and Person C gets more benefits by investing in stocks.
The rate of tax on income, which includes indifference, is lower.
Solve the equations to get the value of personal tax rate.
Derived equation: 1
Derived equation: 2
Note:
Corporate tax percentage is 35%
Find
Hence, the rate of personal tax is 10.50%.
d)
To discuss: The reason whether a low dividend payout ratio has a compelling argument or not
Explanation of Solution
Yes, the low dividend payout ratio has a compelling argument and it has some legal constraints, which restricts the firms from investing their money in the stocks of other companies.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 17 Solutions
Fundamentals of Corporate Finance
- At this point, you may be confused why calling part of your in- vestment debt or equity makes a difference. Let’s walk through an example and compute your post-tax returns. Suppose $2 million of your investment is structured as debt and the remaining $8 million is equity. What happens each year after the company is set up? Well, using the $4 million EBIT, the company will first pay $2 million 50% = $1 million interest to you (as a debt investor). Then, on the remaining $4 $1 = $3 million of EBIT, the company pays corporate taxes of $3 20% = $0.6 million and is left with $2.4 million, which will be paid out to you (the equity holder) as dividend. Income Statement EBIT 4 -Interest expense 1 -Corporate taxes .6 = Net income of 2.4 million Therefore, the total returns to you (as an investor) is $1 million in interest and $2.4 million in dividends, which is a total of $3.4 million.4 Uncle Sam collected $0.6 million. The company will go bankrupt if its EBIT is strictly less than interest…arrow_forward8. Palo Alto Enterprises has £300,000 in cash. They wish to invest the money in Treasury bills at 8% rate of return and use the returns to pay dividends to shareholders after a year. Alternatively, they can pay a dividend and allow shareholders to make the investment. In perfect capital markets and no transaction costs and tax rates, which option will shareholders prefer? A. immediate cash dividend B. dividend after one year C. prefer half from each source D. indifferent between optionsarrow_forwardSuppose the corporate tax rate is 38%, and investors pay a tax rate of 25% on income from dividends or capital gains and a tax rate of 35.5% on interest income. Your firm decides to add debt so it will pay an additional $15 million in interest each year. It will pay this interest expense by cutting its dividend. By how much will the firm need to cut its dividend each year to pay this interest expense?arrow_forward
- Marcus Inc., a manufacturing firm with no debt outstanding and a market value of $100 million is considering borrowing $ 40 million and buying back stock. Assuming that the interest rate on the debt is 9% and that the firm faces a tax rate of 21%, answer the following question: Estimate the present value of all future interest tax savings, assuming that the debt change is permanent. Group of answer choices a. 21m b. 8.4m c. 0.756m d. 1.89marrow_forwardplz use excel and show formula Meyer & Co. expects its EBIT to be $97,000 every year forever. The firm can borrow at 8 percent. The company currently has no debt, and its cost of equity is 13 percent. The tax rate is 24 percent. What is the value of the firm? What is the value if the company borrows $195,000 and uses the proceeds to repurchase shares? What is the cost of equity after recapitalization?What is the WACC? What are the implications of the firm’s decision to borrow?arrow_forwardHow to find ths using a Financial calculator!! Suppose that Glamour Nails, Inc.'s capital structure features 40 percent equity, 60 percent debt, and that its before-tax cost of debt is 5 percent, while its cost of equity is 12 percent. If the appropriate weighted average tax rate is 40 percent, what will be Glamour Nails' WACC? 4.78 percent 4.85 percent 6.60 percent 7.00 percentarrow_forward
- D4) Finance The Grant Corporation is considering permanently adding $500 million of debt to its capital structure. Grant's corporate tax rate is 35% and investors pay a tax rate of 40% on their interest income and 20% on their income from capital gains and dividends. Using Miller’s (1977) model calculate the present value of the interest tax shield provided by this new debt. Please round your answer to the nearest 0.01. 33.33 million 50.00 million 66.67 million 80 million None of the abovearrow_forwardMf1. Please help answer this: Company XYZ is planning to repurchase part of its stock by issuing corporate debt. The firm’s debt-equity ratio will rise from 40% to 50 %. Currently, the firm has 50,000 debt outstanding. The cost of debt is 20% per year. The firm expects to have an EBIT of 25,000 per year in perpetuity. The firm XYZ pays no taxes. (You might need to use Modigliani-Miller Propositions to answer some of the questions.) a) What is the market value of firm XYZ before and after the stock repurchase? b) What is the expected return on the firm’s equity (ROE) before the announcement of the stock repurchase plan? c) What is the expected return on the equity of an identical all-equity firm? d) What is the expected return on the firm’s equity after the announcement of the stock repurchase plan?arrow_forward5:19 You are considering an investment in Fields and Struthers, Inc., and want to evaluate the firm's free cash flow. From th statement, you see that Fields and Struthers earned an EBIT of $84 million, had a tax rate of 21 percent, and its depre was $10 million. Fields and Struthers's NOPAT gross fixed assets increased by $50 million from 2020 and 2021. The f assets increased by $38 million and spontaneous current liabilities increased by $25 million. Calculate Fields and Struthers's NOPAT operating cash flow for 2021. (Enter your answer in millions of dollars round places.) Answer is complete but not entirely correct. $ 11.60 million Operating cash flow Calculate Fields and Struthers's NOPAT investment in operating capital for 2021. (Enter your answer in millions of dolla Investment in operating capital millionarrow_forward
- Give typing answer with explanation and conclusion SeattleHealth Plans currently uses zero-debt financing. Its operating profit is $1 million, and it pays taxes at a 23 percent rate. It has $8 million in assets and, because it is all-equity financed, $8 million in equity. Suppose the firm is considering replacing 22 percent of its equity financing with debt financing that bears an interest rate of 5 percent. What impact would the new capital structure have on the firm's profit?arrow_forwardChoose a,b,c,d,e for the following: Question 3 - Firm U has an EBIT of $10 million and is 100% equity-financed while Firm L, which also has an EBIT of $10 million, uses $100,000 as debt in its capital structure. The interest rate is 6% p.a. and both firms are subject to a 25% tax rate. Based on this information, which of the following is true? a. The value of Firm L is the same as the value of Firm U. b. The tax paid by Firm L is $2,500,000. c. The value of Firm L exceeds the value of Firm U by $1,500. d. Firm U pays lesser tax than Firm L. e. The cash flow from L is $7,501,500.arrow_forwardOnly need help on how to find the WACC using excel, please show formulas, thank you Meyer & Co. expects its EBIT to be $97,000 every year forever. The firm can borrow at 8 percent. The company currently has no debt, and its cost of equity is 13 percent. The tax rate is 24 percent. What is the value of the firm? What is the value if the company borrows $195,000 and uses the proceeds to repurchase shares? What is the cost of equity after recapitalization? What is the WACC? What are the implications of the firm’s decision to borrow?arrow_forward
- EBK CONTEMPORARY FINANCIAL MANAGEMENTFinanceISBN:9781337514835Author:MOYERPublisher:CENGAGE LEARNING - CONSIGNMENTIntermediate Financial Management (MindTap Course...FinanceISBN:9781337395083Author:Eugene F. Brigham, Phillip R. DavesPublisher:Cengage Learning