Concept explainers
Why are protists considered paraphyletic?
a. They include many extinct forms, including lineages that no longer have any living representatives.
b. They include some but not all descendants of their most recent common ancestor.
c. They represent all of the descendants of a single common ancestor.
d. Not all protists have all of the synapomorphies that define the Eukarya, such as a nucleus.
Introduction:
A protist refers to any eukaryotic organism that has a cell with distinct nucleic acids and other membrane-covered structures. They do not form a clade or a natural group.
Answer to Problem 1TYK
Correct answer:
Therefore, protists are considered paraphyletic as this organism group includes only the most recent common ancestors as their descendants.
Explanation of Solution
Explanation/justification for the correct answer:
Option (b) is given as the protists include only some descendants of their recent common ancestors. The protists are the unicellular eukaryotes. This group of organisms is simple, but very diverse. These organisms do not have common ancestors. They possess different cellular structures, varying life cycles as well as different locomotion modes. They possess characteristics of plants or animals or both. Hence, Option (b) is correct.
Explanation for incorrect answer:
Option (a) is given as they involve extinct forms including the lineages that do not have any living representatives. After studying different protists at the molecular level, it has been found that they do not have common ancestors. The protists have characteristics of the descendants of some of their recent common ancestors. So, it is a wrong answer.
Option (c) is given as they show all the descendants of a single common ancestor. The taxa, which represents the protists does not include all descendants of all of their ancestors. This means that they are paraphyletic and not monophyletic. So, it is a wrong answer.
Option (d) is given as not all protists consist of synapomorphies, which describe the eukarya like the nucleus. Therefore, the protists are paraphyletic because they include only some descendants of a single common ancestor. They do not include lineages that no longer have any living representatives. The protists are those eukaryotes that are neither animals, plants, nor fungi, but they all possess a well-defined nucleus. So, it is a wrong answer.
Hence, options (a), (c), and (d) are incorrect.
Therefore, it can be concluded that the protists are known as paraphyletic because they involve some descendants of their recent common ancestor.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 27 Solutions
Biological Science (7th Edition)
- You have discovered a photosynthetic protist that lives in fairly deep water (for example, 250 m deep). To which of the following groups should this organism be classified? A. diatoms B. green algae C. red algae D. cercozoanarrow_forwardWhy is 'protists' considered a polyphyletic grouping? Why do biologists still use it?arrow_forwardWe discussed two theories of the evolution of multicellularity in the animals, the Colonial Theory and the Syncytial Theory. For each of the two theories, give a brief summary of the theory and describe the characteristics you would expect to find in the protist ancestor proposed by each theory.arrow_forward
- Which of the following does not explain why slime molds and multicellular algae are included in the Kingdom Protoctista? They A. lack important characteristics of the plants and fungi. B. use an amoeboid type of movement. C. classification system is trying to reflect phylogenetic relationships. D. appear to be more closely related to unicellular eukaryotes.arrow_forwardModern taxonomic treatments rely heavily on phylogenetic data to classify organisms. In the past, taxonomists often used a morphological species concept, in which species were defined based on similarities in growth form. Give an example of how a morphological species concept would group a set of protists differently from how a phylogenetic species concept would.arrow_forwardGive three examples of protists for which the classifications haverecently changed. In each case, what was the justification for the oldcategory, and what is the justification for the change?arrow_forward
- Why is the classification of protists based on DNA sequences useful? * a. Because only protists have DNA b. Because it has confirmed the traditional categories for protists c. Because it has revealed evolutionary relationships, even among organisms that look diffferent d. All of the above are correct This is a required question (2) Why is a species with small population more likely than one with a large population to undergo an extinction? * a. Because small population are exposed to greater environmental changes b. Because genetic diversity is likely to be lower in a small population c. Because the mutation rate is too low d. Because they take too long to produce an offspring.arrow_forwardWhich of the following is not true about green algae? A. They are a morphologically diverse group B. They are the closest living relatives of land plants C. The group includes the most recent common ancestor and all the descendants D. They share several morphological similarities with land plantsarrow_forwardWhich of the following is thought to be the most closely related to the common animal ancestor? a. fungal cells b. protist cells c. plant cells d. bacterial cellsarrow_forward
- Explain why protists are not considered a clade.arrow_forwardIn the tree of life, which taxon does not belong to the Archaeplastida? A. green algae B. Charophyta C. flowering plants D. diatoms E. Red algaearrow_forwardWhich of the following statements is the MOST compelling argument that fungi are more closely related to animals than plants? A. Plants have chloroplasts whereas fungi and animals cells do not. B. Plants fix carbon dioxide from the air; fungi and animals use pre-existing organic molecules. C. The DNA sequences of ribosomal RNA of fungi share more homology with ribosomal RNA from animals than plants. D. Both animal and fungal cells are eukaryotic.arrow_forward
- Biology (MindTap Course List)BiologyISBN:9781337392938Author:Eldra Solomon, Charles Martin, Diana W. Martin, Linda R. BergPublisher:Cengage Learning