Henry Cabot Lodge’s speech (Document B) expresses a more similar message to the political cartoon (Document C) because both sources oppose the League of Nations. The League of Nations was introduced in the Treaty of Versailles. This League provided a place for countries to meet, settle disputes peacefully, and punish any nation that broke the peace. At the time the league was introduced, there started to be a heated debate to weather the United States should be involved. Henry Cabot Lodge’s speech (Document B) has a similar message to the political cartoon because both of these sources prove that the League of NAtions is harmful or has a negative effect to the United States.
In Henry Cabot Lodge’s speech, (Document B) presented on August 12, 1919, he emphasizes the idea that the League of Nation will be a bad thing for the United States. In his speech, he states “The United States is the world's best hope, but if you fetter her in the interest and quarrel of other nations, if you tangle her in the intrigues of Europe, you will destroy her power for good and endanger her very existence. Leave her to march freely through the centuries to come as in the years that
…show more content…
This illustration explains that the United States joining the League of Nations would be a bad move where it will be pulled in different directions where the United States cannot make its own decisions. This illustration will be showing that the United States is in this mess, that is the League of Nations, and that it needs to get out of the mess. This is how the political cartoon (Document C) is related to Henry Cabot Lodge’s speech (Document B) because both of these sources oppose the League of Nations and these sources prove that the League will be harmful to the United
The League of Nations was established in 1919 after the deadly and devastating conflict of World War I. The nations of the world needed a way to rebuild and regain trust in one another after this worldwide atrocity. President Woodrow Wilson believed that an international peacekeeping organization, such as the League of Nations, could achieve this monumental goal. President Wilson was convinced that the League could prevent another wWorld wWar, preserve peace, and promote total disarmament among nations. Wilson went to the Treaty of Versailles negotiations with a Fourteen Point Plan for peace, but he sacrificed almost all of his plans so that the League of Nations could be established. This organization, however, would never live up to the President’s dreams for its success. Despite Woodrow Wilson’s support for the League of Nations, it failed as a peace keeping organization because the United States did not participate, its decision making process was ineffective, and it lacked an armed force to impose its decisions.
A rhetorical question is a question posed to emphasize a point, not for the purpose of getting an answer. Henry uses this device extensively throughout his speech. Find one example in the speech, quote it and explain what point he is emphasizing with those particular questions.
The Treaty of Versailles had a great chance of being ratified if only President Wilson would have been able to make small amendments. The reservationists had a strong argument about the pros of a League of Nations, but they disagreed with Article 10, which gave the League’s
Many factors contribute to a group of people failing to accomplish a goal, but the stubbornness of participants often is a leading cause. The Senate’s failure to ratify the Treaty of Versailles in 1919 shows this idea, due to the feud between President Woodrow Wilson and the Internationalists, and Henry Cabot Lodge and the Reservationists. The Internationalists fully supported the passing of the Treaty of Versailles, whereas the Reservationists believed it was necessary to change the Treaty, specifically Article Ten. Similarly, Borah and the Irreconcilables believed that the League of Nations was in conflict with one of the ideals the nation was founded on; to not engage in foreign entanglements. As Senator William Borah, put it, the League
Lodge was a Republican senator and believed that, “I will go as far as anyone in world service that the first step to world service is the maintenance of the United States. You may call me selfish if you will, conservative or reactionary, or use any other harsh adjective you see fit to apply… And when I think of the United States first in an arrangement like this, I am thinking of what is best for the world” (Lodge). Many individuals agreed with this statement and felt that Senator Lodge’s strongest and most powerful argument was, “For if we stumble and fall, freedom and civilization everywhere will go down in ruins” (Lodge). This statement alone could have ultimately swayed the voting. It is evident that Senator Lodge overcame his opponent since the United States did not join the League of Nations. His opinion won this fight since his argument was the strongest and his words resonated with many people. Without the help of Senator Henry Cabot Lodge’s speech, the voting could have been different, thus, changing
The United states should not have joined the league of nations in 1919. The United States shouldn’t have joined the league of nations because we would be supplying the troops and food a lot and not getting anything out of it, and we were in no danger of an attack.
Wilson's peace plan, known as the Fourteen Points, introduced the idea of the League of Nations. The League of Nations would bind together all of the countries involved in order to resolve conflicts peacefully and protect independence. Wilson very much wanted the United States to be a part of the League, which would prevent a return to isolationism (Document G). Article Ten of the Treaty of Versailles outlines some of the obligations attached to being a member of the League. This article states that if any nation who is a part of the League is under attack or in danger, all other countries are mandated to come to their aid (Document E). The League of Nations, and this article in particular, caused a great deal of controversy in the U.S. Henry Cabot Lodge, a Reservationist senator, gave a speech to show his objection to the League. Lodge believed the United States should focus its efforts on self-betterment, rather than being forced to "play the part of umpire" in European affairs of no direct interest (Document D). Lodge's discontent with the circumstances that would be created by the League were also shared by the majority of senators, leading to the rejection of the Treaty of Versailles. This decision allowed the U.S. to return to its former isolated
George Washington was an American politician and soldier who served as the first President. George Washington was born February 22, 1732. George washington was raised in Moreland County virginia. George Washington first job was a commander of the army. He was the first president of United State. George Washington was determined retire from the public life after the revolutionary war of United State. He was appointed in our country.
Describe the two flaws in this institution suffered from and explain how these ultimately led to its failure.
In 1918 the US senate got together and consulted on the idea of the League of Nations. The League of Nations was brought the Senate and was not passed because the majority voted against the League of Nations. The leader of the republican, henry Cabot Lodge saw some flaws in the League of Nations. One part of the league of nations rules said ”the united states must respect the territorial integrity
Throughout the interwar period, the U.s. Government over and again picked non-snare over support or mediation as the fitting reaction to universal inquiries. Promptly taking after the First World War, Congress rejected U.s. participation in the League of Nations. A few parts of Congress restricted participation in the League out of worry that it might draw the United States into European clashes, despite the fact that eventually the group security provision sank the likelihood of U.s. support. Throughout the 1930s, the League demonstrated insufficient despite developing militarism, mostly because of the U.s. choice not to take part.
Hi Heather, I do not agree with your argument. The political dispute between Wilson and Lodge was not the only reason that the United States did not join the League of Nations. Some of the inhabitants of America, like the Irish people, were against the League of Nations. You said that "the League of Nations would have kept global peace for everyone", but I contend to this because not all of the nations in the world were included in the League of Nations. This League was not favorable to all Americans' native countries. Also, I do not believe that the League of Nations would have prevented the U.S. from going into World War II, I only think it would have delayed us going into WWII. Since the League of Nations was a newfounded idea, it most likely
In our simulated discussion, it was understood that the League of Nations was established to promote peace; therefore our class generally seemed to follow in the footsteps of the actual conference; yet, there were some noteworthy differences. To begin, Germany was be granted entrance into the League one year after signing the treaty. This decision was particularly upsetting to France, since they had undoubtedly suffered the greatest among the Allies, and were witnessing the extreme
In this essay, I am going to look at the successes and failures of the League of Nations (LofN) in its struggle for peace throughout the 1920’s. The LofN was the ‘brain child’ of American president Woodrow Wilson. The four other main powers (Britain, France, Japan and Italy) joined along with approximately 60 other countries from around the world. The U.S.A then abandoned its ‘child’ as to social and economic unrest led to a more isolationist foreign policy. Yet the other four main countries continued to support the LofN and formed the council, consisting to the ‘most powerful countries’. The LofN was set up to enforce peace in Europe and the world. It created various
"The League of Nations was doomed To failure from the start" Adam Jenner Many may believe that the League of Nations was doomed to failure as soon as the doors of their Geneva headquarters were opened; many may say that it was built on unstable foundations; that the very idea of it was a grave misjudgment by the powers that were. Indeed it is true that the League of Nations, when it was set up was marred with many fundamental flaws. The League of Nations was formed after the end of the First World War. It was an idea that President Wilson introduced as an international police force to maintain peace and to ensure the devastating atrocities like the First World War ever happening again. The principle mission of the League of Nations was to maintain World Peace. Their failure as the international peacekeeping organization to maintain world peace brought the outbreak of Second World War. Their failure in policing and preventing peace in settling disputes throughout Europe, erupted into the most devastating war ever. Through my analysis of the failures of the League of Nations to maintain world peace, my arguments will demonstrate the understandings of the reasons and events that created the most devastating environment for the Second World War.