Ethical Decision Making: A Mini-Case
Mike Lynch is the manager of an upstate New York regional office for an insurance company. As the regional manager, his pay package includes a base salary, commissions, and a bonus, when the region sells new policies in excess of its quota. Mike has been under enormous pressure lately, stemming largely from two factors. First, he is experiencing mounting personal debt due to a family member’s illness. Second, compounding his worries, the region’s sales of new insurance policies have dipped below the normal quota for the first time in years.
You have been working for Mike for two years, and like everyone else in the office, you consider yourself lucky to work for such a supportive boss. You also feel great sympathy for his personal problems over the last few months. In your position as accountant for the regional office, you are only too aware of the drop in new policy sales and the impact this will have on the manager’s bonus. While you are working on the year-end financial statements, Mike stops by your office.
Mike asks you to change the manner in which you have accounted for a new property insurance policy for a large local business. A check for the premium, substantial in amount, came in the mail on December 31, the last day of the reporting year. The premium covers a period beginning on January 5. You deposited the check and correctly debited Cash and credited Unearned Revenue. Mike says, “Hey, we have the money this year, so why not count the revenue this year? I never did understand why you accountants are so picky about these things anyway. I’d like you to change the way you’ve recorded the transaction. I want you to credit a revenue account. And anyway, I’ve done favors for you in the past, and I am asking for such a small thing in return.” With that, he leaves your office.
Required:
How should you handle this situation? What are the ethical implications of Mike’s request? Who are the parties who would be helped or harmed if you went along with the request? If you fail to comply with his request, how will you explain your position to him? Justify your answers in writing.
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter 3 Solutions
Fundamentals Of Financial Accounting
- Cost Information and Ethical Behavior, Service Organization Jean Erickson, manager and owner of an advertising company in Charlotte, North Carolina, arranged a meeting with Leroy Gee, the chief accountant of a large, local competitor. The two are lifelong friends. They grew up together in a small town and attended the same university. Leroy is a competent, successful accountant but is having some personal financial difficulties after some of his investments turned sour, leaving him with a 15,000 personal loan to pay offjust when his oldest son is starting college. Jean, on the other hand, is struggling to establish a successful advertising business. She had recently acquired the rights to open a branch office of a large regional advertising firm headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia. During her first 2 years, she was able to build a small, profitable practice. However, the chance to gain a significant foothold in Charlotte hinged on the success of winning a bid to represent the state of North Carolina in a major campaign to attract new industry and tourism. The meeting she had scheduled with Leroy concerned the bid she planned to submit. Jean: Leroy, Im at a critical point in my business venture. If I can win the bid for the states advertising dollars, Ill be set. Winning the bid will bring 600,000 to 700,000 of revenues into the firm. On top of that, I estimate that the publicity will bring another 200,000 to 300,000 of new business. Leroy: I understand. My boss is anxious to win that business as well. It would mean a huge increase in profits for my firm. Its a competitive business, though. As new as you are, I doubt that youll have much chance of winning. Jean: Youre forgetting two very important considerations. First, I have the backing of all the resources and talent of a regional firm. Second, I have some political connections. Last year, I was hired to run the publicity side of the governors campaign. He was impressed with my work and would like me to have this business. I am confident that the proposals I submit will be very competitive. My only concern is to submit a bid that beats your firm. If I come in with a lower bid and good proposals, the governor can see to it that I get the work. Leroy: Sounds promising. If you do win, however, there will be a lot of upset people. After all, they are going to claim that the business should have been given to local advertisers, not to some out-of-state firm. Given the size of your office, youll have to get support from Atlanta. You could take a lot of heat. Jean: True. But I am the owner of the branch office. That fact alone should blunt most of the criticism. Who can argue that Im not a local? Listen, with your help, I think I can win this bid. Furthermore, if I do win it, you can reap some direct benefits. With that kind of business, I can afford to hire an accountant, and Ill make it worthwhile for you to transfer jobs. I can offer you an up-front bonus of 15,000. On top of that, Ill increase your annual salary by 20%. That should solve most of your financial difficulties. After all, we have been friends since day oneand what are friends for? Leroy: Jean, my wife would be ecstatic if I were able to improve our financial position as quickly as this opportunity affords. I certainly hope that you win the bid. What kind of help can I provide? Jean: Simple. To win, all I have to do is beat the bid of your firm. Before I submit my bid, I would like you to review it. With the financial skills you have, it should be easy for you to spot any excessive costs that I may have included. Or perhaps I included the wrong kind of costs. By cutting excessive costs and eliminating costs that may not be directly related to the project, my bid should be competitive enough to meet or beat your firms bid. Required: 1. What would you do if you were Leroy? Fully explain the reasons for your choice. What do you suppose the code of conduct for Leroys company would say about this situation? 2. What is the likely outcome if Leroy agrees to review the bid? Is there much risk to him personally if he reviews the bid? Should the degree of risk have any bearing on his decision?arrow_forwardEmployee retention is a major goal for Dynamic Thermoforming, Inc.Feedback from the employees had focused on the need for a company-sanctioned retirement program. In response, the company will be offering a 401(k) retirement program complete with a number of different investment choices, including some of the top mutual fund families. In addition, the first 3% of an employee's salary contributed would be fully matched by the company. Quentin Avery, a sales manager with Dynamic Thermoforming, decides to put 3% of his $6,000 monthly salary into an international growth fund offered through the new 401(k) plan. The current net asset value is 17.94 and the year-to-date return is plus 4.9%. How many shares will Quentin be able to purchase each month, and what was the net asset value of the fund at the beginning of the year? Quentin will be able to purchase shares per month. (Round to the nearest hundredth as needed.) The net asset value of the fund at…arrow_forwardDon Masters and two of his colleagues are considering opening a law office in a largemetropolitan area that would make inexpensive legal services available to those whocould not otherwise afford these services. The intent is to provide easy access for theirclients by having the office open 360 days per year, 16 hours each day from 7:00 a.m. to11:00 p.m. The office would be staffed by a lawyer, paralegal, legal secretary, andclerk-receptionist for each of the two 8-hour shifts.In order to determine the feasibility of the project, Don hired a marketing consultantto assist with market projections. The results of this study show that if the firm spends$500,000 on advertising the first year, the number of new clients expected each daywould have the following probability distribution:Don and his associates believe these numbers are reasonable and are prepared tospend the $500,000 on advertising. Other pertinent information about the operation ofthe office is as follows.The only charge to…arrow_forward
- John Milton and two of his colleagues are considering opening a law office in New York City that would make inexpensive legal services available to those who could not otherwise afford these services. The intent is to provide easy access for their clients by having the office open 360 days per year, 16 hours each day from 7:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. The office would be staffed by a lawyer, paralegal, legal secretary, and clerk-receptionist for each of the two 8-hour shifts. In order to determine the feasibility of the project, John hired a marketing consultant to assist with market projections. The results of this study show that if the firm spends $500,000 on advertising the first year, the number of new clients expected each day would have the following probability distribution: Number of New Clients per Day Probability 20 0.10 30 0.30 55 0.40 85 0.20 John and his associates believe these numbers are reasonable and are prepared to spend the $500,000 on advertising. Other pertinent…arrow_forwardAnita Brown is the manager of a wholesale food company. Her compensation, in part, is incentive-based. In other words, the higher the company income, the higher her incentive compensation. Each year, in an effort to influence her bonus, Anita makes several recommendations, concerning adjusting entries, to the company controller. One of her favorites is to ask the controller to reduce the estimate of doubtful accounts.1. How does lowering the estimate of doubtful accounts affect the income statement and balance sheet?2. Is there an ethical consideration in this case? If so, what is it?3. Should Anita be permitted to weigh in on adjusting entries under these circumstances? Why or why not?arrow_forwardLon Timur is an accounting major at a midwestern state university located approximately 60 miles from a major city. Many of the students attending the university are from the metropolitan area and visit their homes regularly on the weekends. Lon, an entrepreneur at heart, realizes that few good commuting alternatives are available for students doing weekend travel. He believes that a weekend commuting service could be organized and run profitably from several suburban and downtown shopping mall locations. Lon has gathered the following investment information. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Five used vans would cost a total of $75,000 to purchase and would have a 3-year useful life with negligible salvage value. Lon plans to use straight-line depreciation. Ten drivers would have to be employed at a total payroll expense of $48,000. Other annual out-of-pocket expenses associated with running the commuter service would include Gasoline $16,000, Maintenance $3,300, Repairs $4,000, Insurance $4,200, and…arrow_forward
- Lon Timur is an accounting major at a midwestern state university located approximately 60 miles from a major city. Many of the students attending the university are from the metropolitan area and visit their homes regularly on the weekends. Lon, an entrepreneur at heart, realizes that few good commuting alternatives are available for students doing weekend travel. He believes that a weekend commuting service could be organized and run profitably from several suburban and downtown shopping mall locations. Lon has gathered the following investment information. 1. Five used vans would cost a total of $75,551 to purchase and would have a 3-year useful life with negligible salvage value. Lon plans to use straight-line depreciation. 2. Ten drivers would have to be employed at a total payroll expense of $48,300. 3. Other annual out-of-pocket expenses associated with running the commuter service would include Gasoline $16,200, Maintenance $3,300, Repairs $3,800, Insurance…arrow_forwardYou are the senior accountant for Terrier Company and the Board of Directors is discussing the possibility of implementing a retirement plan for the employees of the company. They have asked for your guidance on whether they should move forward with creating a plan for retirement benefits, and if so, what type of plan would be beneficial to the employees while also creating the least amount of risk for the company (from an accounting and economic standpoint). Prepare a memo to the Board addressing the 3 choices they have: 1) Do not implement a plan 2) Implement a defined contribution plan 3) Implement a defined benefit plan. In your memo you should define each type of plan (DC vs. DB) and describe the pro’s and con’s of each of the 3 choices. Pro/con arguments should be focused on both the impact to the financial statements AND the impact to the employees of the organization (and how that could ultimately hurt or benefit the business). You should use at least 3 outside sources to…arrow_forwardJason Kemp was torn between conflicting emotions. On the one hand, things were going so well. He had just completed 6 months as the assistant financial manager in the Electronics Division of Med-Products Inc. The pay was good, he enjoyed his coworkers, and he felt that he was part of a team that was making a difference in American health care. On the other hand, his latest assignment was causing some sleepless nights. Mel Cravens, his boss, had asked him to “refine” the figures on the division’s latest project—a portable imaging device code—named ZM. The original estimates called for investment of $15.6 million and projected annual income of $1.87 million. Med-Products required an ROI of at least 15% for new project approval. So far, ZM’s rate of return was nowhere near that hurdle rate. Mel encouraged him to show increased sales and decreased expenses in order to get the projected income above $2.34 million. Jason asked for a meeting with Mel to voice his concerns. Jason: Mel, I’ve…arrow_forward
- Jason Kemp was torn between conflicting emotions. On the one hand, things were going so well. He had just completed 6 months as the assistant financial manager in the Electronics Division of Med-Products Inc. The pay was good, he enjoyed his coworkers, and he felt that he was part of a team that was making a difference in American health care. On the other hand, his latest assignment was causing some sleepless nights. Mel Cravens, his boss, had asked him to “refine” the figures on the division’s latest project—a portable imaging device code—named ZM. The original estimates called for investment of $15.6 million and projected annual income of $1.87 million. Med-Products required an ROI of at least 15% for new project approval. So far, ZM’s rate of return was nowhere near that hurdle rate. Mel encouraged him to show increased sales and decreased expenses in order to get the projected income above $2.34 million. Jason asked for a meeting with Mel to voice his concerns. Jason: Mel, I’ve…arrow_forwardYou are the senior accountant for Terrier Company and the Board of Directors is discussing the possibility of implementing a retirement plan for the employees of the company. They have asked for your guidance on whether they should move forward with creating a plan for retirement benefits, and if so, what type of plan would be beneficial to the employees while also creating the least amount of risk for the company (from an accounting and economic standpoint). Prepare a memo to the Board addressing the 3 choices they have: 1) Do not implement a plan 2) Implement a defined contribution plan 3) Implement a defined benefit plan. In your memo you should define each type of plan (DC vs. DB) and describe the pro's and con's of each of the 3 choices. Pro/con arguments should be focused on both the impact to the financial statements AND the impact to the employees of the organization (and how that could ultimately hurt or benefit the business). You should use at least 3 outside sources to…arrow_forwardRay is a finance director in a public sector organization that has experienced difficulty attracting and retaining skilled staff. To assist in overcoming this problem, the board has engaged a consultant to recommend an improved benefits structure, to apply to all staff. The consultant has produced his report, and Ray has been asked to consider the proposed staff benefits structure, and make appropriate recommendations to the board. He study the report, conduct appropriate research, and assess the costs involved. He concludes that it will be necessary to increase staff costs, but believes these will be offset by the efficiencies brought about by recruiting and retaining high-quality staff. The report contains the following recommendations: Benefits should be related to the length of service of members of staff. After one year of continuous employment, a member of staff will qualify for private health insurance. Private health insurance should cover the member of staff and his or her…arrow_forward
- Cornerstones of Cost Management (Cornerstones Ser...AccountingISBN:9781305970663Author:Don R. Hansen, Maryanne M. MowenPublisher:Cengage LearningManagerial Accounting: The Cornerstone of Busines...AccountingISBN:9781337115773Author:Maryanne M. Mowen, Don R. Hansen, Dan L. HeitgerPublisher:Cengage Learning